Don’t have the time to search the market for the best cookie presses?
We got you covered. Upon testing a multitude of cookie presses, we sampled out the best of the best after a thorough analysis which is why we are here today.
Whether young or old, we all do enjoy our favorite flavor of cookies. This, however, can be made better if we can shape them in different shapes, which brings us to the importance of a cookie press. With cookie press, you should be able to shape your cookies as preferred. This not only adds fun to your baking process but it allows you to make the cookies best suited for specific events.
In today’s reviews, we’ll be looking into 11 of the best presses you could invest in for reliability, versatility, and durability.
Without further ado, let’s find out how you can give your cookies an amazing visual delight and much more…
Quick comparison of the best cookie presses in 2021
OXO 1257580 Good Grips Cookie Press – Best Cookie Press for Cheese Straws
Marcato 8300 Atlas Biscuit Maker Press – Cookie Press with Crank Handle
Lacor 68989 Pistoled Pour Patisserie – Commercial Cookie Press
Wilton Preferred Press Cookie Press, 13-Piece – Professional Cookie Press
Fante’s 12007 Easy Cookie Press – Italian Style Cookie Press
Wilton Simple Success Cookie Press – Best Spritz Cookie Press
Deluxe Spritz Cookie Press Gun – Old Fashioned Cookie Press
Cuisinart CTG-00-CP Cookie Press – Christmas Cookie Press
Nostalgia CDP200RED Retro Series Cookie Dough Press – Best Electric Cookie Presses
VINTAGE Mirro Cooky Cookie Press – Vintage Cookie Press
What is a cookie press?
If you are tired of the monotony of baking round-shaped and plain cookies, then a cookie press is what you need. As much as a cookie-cutter may add a touch of creativity to your baking, a cookie press does much more than this.
For starters, it’s easy to use and works much faster. As far as accuracy and reliability are concerned, a cookie press is also more practical and you can get lots of different shapes for different events. What’s even more interesting is that you can use either a manual or an electric press.
I’d recommend the electric if consistency is a priority and a manual one if you want to have a fun time when baking.
On to the main agenda, it’s time to find out how you can give your cookies an amazing visual delight by creating lots of different attractive shapes.
Our Top 10 Best Cookie Press Reviews of 2021
1- OXO 1257580 Good Grips Cookie Press
Boasting an ergonomic lever, this will be comfortable to hold and use even when handling a large batch of cookies. Speaking of comfort, the non-slip base always ensures it adheres to the cooking sheet for consistency.
For easy component storage, there’s a storage case for keeping the 12 stainless steel discs. These are durable and since they can be used on different occasions, you get versatility at its best.
Since it comes apart easily, the OXO 1257580 allows for both easy cleaning and filling.
Pros
- It’s easy to assemble.
- You can be able to see the dough level.
- Features a convenient storage case.
Cons
- Adhere to cookie recipes for the best results.
<strong>Check Latest Price on Amazon</strong>
2- Marcato 8300 Atlas Biscuit Maker Press
You can also easily adjust the cookie sizes with just the turn of a knob. As for the capacity, you can end up with a maximum of 40 small cookies and 25 large cookies. For the construction, it’s a blend of ABS plastic and anodized aluminum which should also be easy to clean.
Using this is also quite easy and neat. You don’t have to worry about rolling or cutting through the sticky and messy dough. Simply remove the top cover, fill with dough, replace the top and press the handle.
Pros
- Easy to put together and disassemble.
- It comes with 20 discs for multiple cookie shapes..
- Made from high-quality aluminum and ABS plastic
Cons
- The barrel’s capacity is low.
<strong>Check Latest Price on Amazon</strong>
3- Lacor 68989 Pistoled Pour Patisserie
For such a compact cookie press, the barrel size is decent enough to get a fair number of cookies done. You may, however, have to fill it a couple of times if you are making a large batch which though annoying, is a trade-off for the compact design.
There’s more…
Besides just being a convenient cookie press, it happens to be just as good for icing since it comes with multiple icing sets. This is also quite easy to use, thanks to the easy action icing syringe included in the design.
Pros
- Made of light stainless steel.
- It can be used for icing as well.
- Has got an easy action syringe.
Cons
- Not ideal for large batches of cookies.
<strong>Check Latest Price on Amazon</strong>
4- Wilton Preferred Press Cookie Press, 13-Piece
With durable metal and plastic construction, longevity will be amazing. Still, on the design, the base is raised and as such, it’s easy to switch between the 12 different discs. Also, when it comes to cleaning, all you need is warm, soapy water to remove the dough and a quick rinse.
Owing to its hourglass shape, it is comfortable to hold. Speaking of comfort, there is a soft grip trigger that lets the dough out with minimum effort.
Pros
- Features a convenient see-through barrel.
- It comes with a comfortable soft-grip trigger.
- Features 12 interchangeable discs.
Cons
- The direction of use is a little confusing.
<strong>Check Latest Price on Amazon</strong>
5- Fante’s 12007 Easy Cookie Press
First things first, it’s easy to switch between any of the 5 different cookie shapes it comes with. This way, you’re saved from the hassle of using cookie cutters or the mess that comes with rolling dough.
With each handle turn, the dough is smoothly extruded with amazing consistency each time. What’s even more interesting is that you don’t have to put too much effort into it- it’s amazingly easy to use.
Once you are done, disassembly is just as easy as assembly and the same goes for the cleaning. Simply hand wash this in warm, soapy water then dry it thoroughly.
Pros
- It’s easy to load the dough and use it.
- Has got 5 traditional cookie shapes.
- Easy to clean up.
Cons
- Ensure the dough is not too thick for effortless handle turns.
<strong>Check Latest Price on Amazon</strong>
6- Wilton Simple Success Cookie Press
First, the handle is ergonomic and comfortable as it comes with a soft gripper. As for the dough barrel, this is crystal clear and allows you to see how much dough you have remaining. In addition to this, you can also be able to choose from either of 12 different cookie discs which makes’ this one of the best spritz cookie presses.
As for cleaning, you only need to hand wash it in warm, soapy water, rinse off the soap and dry it thoroughly. No better way to easily and quickly make consistent spritz cookies.
Pros
- Features a clear barrel.
- Comes with 12 discs for versatility.
- Includes a comfortable and ergonomic handle.
Cons
- The barrel capacity could do better.
<strong>Check Latest Price on Amazon</strong>
7- Deluxe Spritz Cookie Press Gun
Also included in the package are 20 amazing decorative stencils which get you beautifully crafted cookies. Regardless of the stencil chosen, you can also easily adjust the cookie size by pressing down on the knob then turning it.
Besides the decorative stencils, 4 icing tips make using this fun. To give you the utmost convenience, you can get as much as 40 small cookies and 25 larger ones from a full chamber.
Pros
- Has got a sturdy aluminum and stainless-steel design.
- It comes with a large capacity chamber.
- Features 20 decorative designs.
Cons
- The ratcheting system is a little weak.
<strong>Check Latest Price on Amazon</strong>
8- Cuisinart CTG-00-CP Cookie Press
Considering that the Cuisinart CTG-00-CP has got a transparent barrel, you should be able to know when the dough level is low. Also, to make things easy for you if you’re a beginner, there is a recipe booklet included with this.
As far as cleaning is concerned, it’s dishwasher safe which is quite comforting since it can be a little difficult to get in some spots by hand.
Here’s more…
Other than getting just the cookie discs, there are also 6 decorating tips included with this bad boy for unlimited creativity.
Pros
- Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.
- Features 18 design discs and 6 decorating tips.
- Comes with a recipe booklet.
Cons
- Ensure the dough is soft enough.
<strong>Check Latest Price on Amazon</strong>
9- Nostalgia CDP200RED Retro Series Cookie Dough Press
To make it a complete cookie press, you’ll be getting 12 cookie discs with this as well as 12 decoration tips. This way, your creativity is unlimited. Also, being an electric cookie press, usage is quite simple since it only relies on a simple touch of a button.
Here’s more…
Besides just being ideal for making cookies, this press is also amazing for filing pasta shells and decorating cakes. You will also get cookie recipes in the instruction manual which makes it easy to use for a beginner as well.
Pros
- Has got a see-through barrel.
- It comes with 12 cookie disc designs.
- Can make 30 cookies on a full barrel.
Cons
- It’s a little too delicate.
<strong>Check Latest Price on Amazon</strong>
10- VINTAGE Mirro Cooky Cookie Press
With this combination, your creativity won’t be limited whatsoever. Speaking of creativity, there’s also a recipe book that should give you a good head start if you’re a beginner.
To keep everything safe, there is a grooved wooden tray for the discs and the filler tips. As for the build quality, it’s made of durable aluminum that is rust-resistant and not easy to break.
Pros
- It comes with 12 cookie discs and 3 filler tips.
- Includes a wooden tray for storage.
- Has got a recipe guide.
Cons
- It might take some time to get used to it.
<strong>Check Latest Price on Amazon</strong>
What is the best cookie press to buy?
Having looked at some of the top-rated cookie presses in 2020, let’s have a look at what the best cookie press to buy are.
Best Electric Cookie Presses
There are lots of reasons you could get an electric cookie press. For some people, they’d prefer an electric one since they don’t have to put too much effort into using them. Others, on the other hand, may have to use them as a result of health complications such as arthritis.
Like most equipment, electric cookie presses have their advantages and setbacks. If you buy a budget press, it will spin fast and accurately but, on the downside, it will not have enough torque to push refrigerated cooking dough. At this point, you’ll have to get a more expensive cookie press.
In a nutshell, depending on the kind of electric cookie press you have, it’s a really good idea to ensure the dough is soft enough.
My advice to you would be to get a manually powered cookie press if you got healthy hands and only get an electric one if otherwise.
Best Cookie Press for Cheese Straws
Cheese straws are the delicacy of most since they are made from a mixture of flaky pastry and cheese with a light texture.
So, on to the matter at hand, how do you choose a cookie press for making these? Considering they are not remotely shaped like your average cookies, you need to be a little careful of the press you pick.
For starters, if the dough is thick, you’ll need to put in more force on the handle of the press. This means that the handle should not give in to the pressure and not snap off. You should also consider how easy the dough is dispensed out of the press.
At this point, you may have to choose between a manual and electric press in which case I’d advise you to get a manual one.
Something else you’ll want to consider is the number of shapes the press comes with. Simply ensure it’s as versatile as possible to meet your needs.
Best Spritz Cookie Press
On lots of different occasions spritz cookies are the preferred snack for most people. Just as they do come in different recipes, the same goes for the shapes. The thing, however, is that as delicious and attractive as they are, perfecting them is no easy task.
Like everything mechanical, the press should be strong enough to let the dough through without getting stuck or breaking apart. Spritz cookies can be made with both the old fashioned and modern presses.
Which one to use, however, is entirely dependent on your level of expertise and of course patience.
Like most things that are vintage, similar cookie presses are a little difficult to use and not as fast as the modern one’s sine they come with more moving parts. It is also difficult to get accurate shapes with these unless you have years of experience.
When using a modern press, however, everything is easy from assembly to speed, usage, and reliability which is what I’d recommend for you to buy if you’re shopping for an upgrade.
Professional Cookie Press
When it comes to professional baking, you want the results as close to perfect as possible that you’ll be comfortable serving them. As it turns out, there’s no better way to achieve this than with the best cookie press.
First things first, regardless of the kind of cookies you make, ensure the build quality is the best since most likely will have to make lots of cookies. At the same time, versatility ought to be a priority which is why you should go for the best possible size depending on your application.
The rule of thumb when choosing professional ones is going for as many discs as possible. It’s also a good idea to go for one with a large capacity that is at the same time easy to handle. Also, if you’re concerned about the effort of pressing the dough, you should consider choosing between a turning-style, manual press or an electric model.
Christmas Cookie Press
If you’re looking for the best of these, then the best way to go would be choosing an amazing spritz cookie press.
With Christmas being one of the most anticipated holidays, you’ll want the cookies to not only be tasty but also be as attractive as possible.
To best achieve this, simply settle for a cookie press with as many shapes as possible.
Cookie Press with Crank Handle
Crank cookie presses have been around for a long time. They’re the kind of cookie presses that have been passed down families but always seem to get the job done despite being old. Such a cookie press normally has a canister where the dough goes into. On one end of the canister is the end where the crank handle is at and the opposite end is where the disc goes.
As you’ve already guessed, assembly is quite easy. Its usage, on the other hand, is not as easy.
To get the dough going, you’ll need to engage the crank and if it’s your first time, you are most likely to get smashed cookies. it takes some practice to get it right but the idea behind perfecting your shapes is being patient with everything and lifting the press slowly as the dough comes out.
Italian Style Cookie Press
These cookie presses are similar to your usual press with just a slightly different in design. Depending on the one you choose, you can also be able to resize your cookies.
Additionally, they are easy to dismantle. Something else that makes them worth investing in is that they are mostly constructed of aluminum, ABS plastic, or steel.
Also, as far as dismantling them is concerned, they should come apart easily which makes getting them clean for the next use quite easy.
How to use a cookie press
Even though you may have one of the best cookie presses in the market with you, it won’t be any good if you don’t know how to use it. Because of this, allow me to guide you on the whole process of getting this right.
1- Get your cookie press-ready
Unscrew the ring of your barrel (the end opposite to the handle). With this off, you can access the inside of the barrel.
2- Fill the container
Similar to other cooking recipes, the first thing to do would be combining all the required ingredients needed for the cookie dough. The dough should be consistent enough and rolled into a log shape such that it is thin enough to fit into the cookie barrel. Only use cookie recipes as they’ll give you an amazing consistency.
Alternatively, to save time, you could buy pre-made cookie dough which also comes in a log shape. I’d also advise against using dough’s that have big pieces on it like nuts or chocolate chips.
Next, insert the cookie dough into the barrel leaving a little bit of space near the handle to make it easy for you to press out the dough. Once inserted, you can then insert a disc of your desired pattern into the ring.
3- Don’t grease your cookie sheet
For the preparation, as much as you may be tempted to greasing the cookie sheet, doing this will make it difficult for the dough to adhere to the sheet and as such, the cookies will not form properly.
4- Remove air from the press
Having air in your dough will distort their shape and because of this, it’s a good idea to press out excess air from the barrel with the plunger.
Just press down on this till the dough is packed down at the end of the barrel.
5- Hold the press flat on the baking sheet
On to the interesting part, the next thing you’ll need to do is have the press flat on the baking sheet with the barrel vertical.
Most people get it wrong here by having the end of the barrel slightly angled in which case the dough may not stick to the sheet; ensure it’s completely flat.
6- Don’t overload the cookies
While pressing out the dough, don’t overdo it as the cookies may be overloaded and lose their shape as they cook.
7- Practice
Not to worry if you don’t get it right the first time, a little bit of practice with a few presses on the handle or plunger will come in handy.
8- Pause before lifting
Before lifting the cookie press and pushing out the next one on the cookie sheet, pause for a few seconds to allow the dough to take form.
9- Allow space between the cookies
Additionally, when handling the next press, allow for a sensible amount of space as instructed on the recipe you’re using. This should allow for expansion room as they take in the oven heat.
10- Cool the cookies
By adhering to the recommended cooling time on your recipe, allow the cookies to cool after which they should be ready to eat!
11- Allow clean-up time
Now that your baking is all done, take the cookie press apart and clean it. This should be quite simple- unscrew the ring at the barrel end and separate the ring from the disc.
Next, separate the barrel and the handle then remove the flat disc at the plunger end. With everything apart, clean the separate components with warm water.
The best-selling cookie press brands of 2021
To have an easy time shopping for one, cookie presses from either of these brands will be a worthy investment.
OXO Good Grips Cookie Press
When comfort and versatility are a priority, OXO is the brand to settle for since it has lots of shapes plus there is a transparent cylinder so you can see how much dough is remaining.
With a comfortable lever, you can use these repeatedly so they can also be used commercially.
Wilton Comfort Grip Cookie Press
Similar to the OXO press, this one too comes with a transparent barrel plus it is designed to create better shapes. Speaking of shapes, you get a dozen different shapes for versatility.
Kuhn Rikon Clear Cookie Press
With over a dozen interchangeable discs and a see-through plastic barrel, you couldn’t go wrong with this cookie press. As a bonus, there a storage box coming along with this to keep everything safe; which is quite convenient since, as there is a risk of losing the discs it comes with.
Wilton Preferred Cookie Press
It’s amazingly easy to fill the dough with this plus it comes with 12 unique shapes and 4 mini cookie discs. If spritz cookies are your thing, these are the way to go. For the perfect shapes, there’s also a non-slip ring at the bottom to keep it on the surface.
Marcato Atlas Deluxe Cookie Press
Standing out to be one of the best Italian cookies, you can get this in lots of different colors and an amazing 20 designs to choose from. One feature that makes this stand out above most is the ability to adjust the cookie sizes with a simple knob turn.
Cuisinart Electric Cookie Press
With this electric cookie press, you get 10 different shapes and 6 decorating tips. Also, it only needs a one-touch operation to get it working. Considering it’s also dishwasher safe, you couldn’t go wrong with this one.
Wilton Preferred Cookie Press Set
From the clear see-through barrel to see the dough level to the soft trigger grip, this bad boy is designed to make things as easy as possible for you. The construction, being plastic and metal is also quite durable and easy to clean up.
DKST Kitchen Cookie Press Kit
From the large storage case to over half a dozen seasonal discs for crafting your cookies, this could be the spritz cookie press you’ve been searching for. The cylinder is larger it should be good enough for commercial and home use.
Cuisinart CTG-00-GP Cookie Press
Boasting a unique and user-friendly design, this press has a clear tube which makes it easy to fill with dough plus you can also use one of these to fill shells and deviled eggs. Adding on to the fact that it is dishwasher safe, you couldn’t go wrong with this bad boy.
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
Where to buy Marcate cookie press?
This amazing cookie press can be obtained from a trusted online store such as Amazon
What is the number one selling cookie press in America?
The 13-piece Wilton Preferred press is the best selling as it has balanced out on all aspects ranging from durability to versatility and ease of use.
Where is America’s test kitchen located?
It’s located in Boston.
What can I use if I don’t have a cookie press?
An alternative to using a cookie press is using a cookie cutter which is slower but will get the job done.
Are cookie press discs interchangeable?
Yes, they come in different shapes and are easy to switch based on your preference.
How to use an old-fashioned cookie press?
Old cookie presses normally use a crank handle which when turned pushes the dough out hence allowing you to get the desired shapes depending on the disc in use.
How to use a Wilton cookie press?
Like most cookie presses, this has to be held upright with the bottom resting against an ungreased cookie sheet. Next, you should squeeze the trigger to form a cookie.
How to use a cookie stamp?
First, you’ll need to dust it with some flour to prevent sticking. Next, carefully press it on to your cookie shape but not too hard that you go right through the cookie or misshape the cookie.
That’s it.
What brand stove does America’s test kitchen use?
The Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven.
Which cookie press is rated the best?
The Marcato Atlas Deluxe Biscuit Maker Cookie Press.
What is the best cookie press for spritz cookies?
OXO Good Grips Cookie Press. It’s comfortable, easy to use, and delivers consistent cuts.
What is the best cookie press for cheese straws?
The OXO Good Grips Cookie Press is amazing since it has a non-slip base to keep the press steady hence you get neat and uniform straws.
What is a good cookie press?
The secret to getting a good cookie press is dependent on how you’ll be using it. The bottom line, however, is choosing a durable, easy to use and easy to clean cookie press that delivers consistent cuts.
Final verdict
From what we’ve seen, there’s a lot more to a cookie press than meets the eye. If you do want to bake the best cookies, you owe it to yourself to get one of the best cookie presses.
Though it’s a matter of personal preference, always have consistency, durability, and ease of use in mind when shopping for one of these.
Leave a Reply